South Carolina Trust and Estate Law Blog

By MillerLaw



South Carolina Trust
and Estate Law Blog

Greenville Estate Lawyer: “How Can I Have An Estate Representative Removed?”

February 22, 2011

This question comes up alot, and most of the time I cringe when I hear it. I hate to see an inheritance needlessly get eaten up by attorney’s fees, and the removal of the personal representative is one of those proceedings that can lead to unnecessary attorneys fees. I find that most of the time this question arises due to a lack of understanding of the administration of an estate (some people erroneously believe that being appointed as personal representative means they are then entitled to the entire estate), or through a lack of effective communication between the personal representative of the estate and one or more of the estate beneficiaries.

Be that as it may, there are situations that call for the removal of the estate beneficiary, and not surprisingly, S.C. statute lays out the parameters. South Carolina Code Section 62-3-611 (b) says “cause for removal exists when removal would be in the best interests of the estate, or if it is shown that a personal representative or the person seeking his appointment intentionally misrepresented material facts in the proceedings leading to his appointment, or that the personal representative has disregarded an order of the court, has become incapable of discharging the duties of his office, or has mismanaged the estate or failed to perform any duty pertaining to the office.” There you go. You can seek the removal of the personal representative by showing that the personal representative lied to the court on the Application for Appointment (in regard to the identity of estate beneficiaries), offering a knowingly fraudulent Last Will for probate, willfully misrepresenting the value of estate assets, paying invalid claims, commingling estate assets with personal assets, or failure to abide by the time limits imposed on the submission of inventories and accountings.

Absent one of the above circumstances, it will be nearly impossible to have the personal representative involuntarily removed. Particularly when a Last Will nominates a personal representative, there will be great judicial deference to this choice, as again recently stated by the South Carolina Court of Appeals in the case of Church v. McGee et al, “[T]here is a strong deference shown to the personal representative chosen by the testator.” Blackmon, 366 S.C. at 251 “The Courts have ever been reluctant to take management of an estate from those to whom it has been confided by the testator, for to that extent the intention expressed in his will would be defeated.” Id. (quoting Smith v. Heyward, 115 S.C. 145, 164, 105 S.E. 275, 282 (1920). “The power to remove a personal representative should be exercised with great caution, and not at all, unless it is made to appear to be necessary for the protection of the estate, to prevent loss or injury to it from misappropriation, maladministration, or fraud.” Id. quoting Smith, 115 S.C. at 164-65, 105 S.E. 282.

If you believe you are a beneficiary of an estate that is not being appropriately administered, you should consult with an attorney before embarking on a path that may cause needless stress and anxiety.  Sometimes a phone call or letter to the attorney representing the estate will lead to clarification of what is going on with the estate, and when inventories and acountings can be expected to be received.           

Like any decent lawyer, I need to add a disclaimer here: unfortunately, it is impossible to offer comprehensive legal advice over the internet, no matter how well researched or written. And remember, reviewing this website and my blogs doesn’t make you a client of my Firm: before relying on any information given on this site, please contact a legal professional to discuss your particular situation.

Filed under: Estate Administration,Legal Posts — Christopher Miller